Jack and Aston Martin V8 Vantage Monaco street signs
Jack Yan: the Persuader blog
  Click here to go to home pageWhat I stand forMy stuffWhat others have recently saidMeet some of the coolest folks I knowDrop me a line Visit my workplace
> My stuff > The Persuader Blog


Not so, Smart 

is trying to stem losses at its troubled unit and has announced that the -based compact hatchback will cease production. It joins the lovely Smart Roadster and Coupé in the scrapheap in the sky.
   There has been some debate over whether the Smart was wrongly defined, and that this was another DaimlerChrysler gaffe—along with its early mismanagement of and the decline in quality of vehicles.
   I don’t think the brand was bad. The idea is good enough: cars marketed as items. has done it with the , for example. Smart stood for cheekiness, building more on the culture than anything from Mercedes-Benz.
   This may have proved troublesome for DaimlerChrysler, used to selling and finding it hard to adjust to being a ’ company. Hence, it never knew what to do with (so it killed it), and the model explosion at Mercedes-Benz did lead to its gradual slipping down the surveys.
   The original Smart City-Coupé could have been a hit, like the original Swatches. But the Mercedes-Benz ideas came through, namely its . Sure, it may have been an advanced little car—and textbooks did dictate that the advancement and fashion positioning should tend to attract a higher price.
   But did this work with the ? If Swatch meant value, then surely Smart would, too? A high price didn’t gel with the way the car was being promoted, with its cute plastic boxes, apeing watch cases, at dealers.
   With this chasm between what people thought the Smart brand stood for, and the reality as a pricey toy, the little car never revolutionized in the way Swatch took its market by storm in its early days.
   Yet DaimlerChrysler still lost money on the cars. Someone in the department wasn’t doing a decent enough job, using the brand as the lynch-pin that held every other concept in place.
   Meanwhile, claimed that its more “normal” city car, the Lupo, had more room and cost less. But that is not what really killed the Smart.
   Nor did the lack of to Mercedes-Benz , some of whom took on a Smart franchise. The existing customers weren’t going to touch a Smart, and no new ones came because of the high price.
   What killed Smart’s chances was the earlier realization by other manufacturers that small cars should be sold with a bent. By the time the Smart came out, already had its Ka and its Twingo. Both were fairly functional, spirited in their drive, and didn’t suffer from the whiny powerplant and questionable handling of the Smart.
   In essence, the market had value-packed, fashionable cars—the equivalent of —while Smart was trying to tell us it gave you less, and charged more. It was still , but with prices approaching that of .
   And the city-car-as-fashion-item principle hasn’t abated. has its Panda and may come out with a new Cinquecento. Ford will redo the Ka on the same platform. will have a new Corsa soon, while ’s Vitz/Yaris is as funky as they come. Peugeot–Citroën has the 107 and C1, twinned with the Toyota Aygo. Against these, Smart looks like an anomaly, a curiosity like the is today. At least the Smarts will be respectable and earn a great deal of affection as a in 25 to 30 years’ time.
   DaimlerChrysler usually does better with a car’s second outing, and a new Smart ForTwo (ForTwo MarkTwo?) will be out in 2007, the sole car to carry the Smart nameplate. However, the looks fiercer, and I doubt that DaimlerChrysler knows how to reduce the price of a car to really capture the masses.
   Indications show that the next ForTwo won’t be a like the Mini, the Fiat 500, or the Volkswagen Käfer. It will be just another premium-priced , and possibly the last car to have the Smart brand, if things don’t change there.

Del.icio.us tags: Smart | DaimlerChrysler | branding | brand | marketing | fashion | premium | pricing
Post a Comment  Links to this post

Hi Jack - the brand is clearly broken all over the place. Check out my horror story in dealing with that company http://www.emergencemarketing.com/archives/2006/03/mercedes_a_case_study_on.php  
Thank you, François, for the latest. I read Emergence Marketing regularly but it’s nice to get a personal invitation from you. I also agree with everything you said—and that you are not alone. I recall there was a Mercedes-Benz US site set up by an unhappy customer, and I have a few horror stories to tell as well.  
2008 Toyota Aygo is expected to compete with the upcoming 2008 Smart Fortwo. The design resembles some details from the Toyota Yaris hatchback, but the Aygo has a shorter and smaller dimensions.  
Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link




Entries from 2006 to the end of 2009 were done on the Blogger service. As of January 1, 2010, this blog has shifted to a Wordpress installation, with the latest posts here.
   With Blogger ceasing to support FTP publishing on May 1, I have decided to turn these older pages in to an archive, so you will no longer be able to enter comments. However, you can comment on entries posted after January 1, 2010.

Quick links

Surf to the online edition of Lucire
  • More ramblings at the Lucire Insider blog
  • The Medinge Group
  • Jack Yan for Mayor
  • My Facebook page
  • Follow me on Twitter
  • My Vkontakte page
  • Book me for public speaking
  • Contact JY&A Consulting on business projects
  • Check out fonts from JY&A Fonts
  • Add feeds

    Add feed to Bloglines

    Individual JY&A and Medinge Group blogs

  • Lucire: Insider
  • Summer Rayne Oakes
  • The Medinge Group press room
  • Detective Marketing
  • Amanda van Kuppevelt
  • Delineate Brandhouse
  • Paolo Vanossi
  • Nigel Dunn
  • Pameladevi Govinda
  • Endless Road
  • Avidiva news
  • Johnnie Moore’s Weblog
  • Steal This Brand Too
  • The Beyond Branding Blog
  • Ton’s Interdependent Thoughts
  • Partum Intelligendo
  • Right Side up
  • Headshift
  • Goiaba Brazilian Music
  • Jack Yan on Tumblr (brief addenda)

  • +

    Previous posts

  • Cooper v. Cooper (take two)
  • Saddam had WMD, but don’t tell anyone
  • Tag team
  • Journalists in fiction
  • Lotto needs a diet
  • Segmentation can decrease brand loyalty
  • Snakes on a Plane strike back
  • Water, water everywhere
  • Not bad for someone who refused to have his own bl...
  • Because it’s worth it

  • Donate

    If you wish to help with my hosting costs, please feel free to donate.